Slumdogs and us
This is not a film-critic-cultural-event blog, but this time I have to.
I am disappointed with Bollywood "poor boy meets girl and wins lottery because he's nice" story getting 8 Oscars, I really am. The Academy took the feel good route and seriously overdid it with all the cheerful spirit for the times of crisis.
Best song? WTF?
"Milk" and "The Reader" were much more movie movies, "Benjamin Button" was not bad either, but nooo... the happy beggar wins. Bleh. I'm disappointed "Changeling" and "Revolutionary Road" didn't get the recognition they deserved.
As much as I loved Heath Ledger - enough is enough, Philip Seymour Hoffman and Michael Shannon were as good if not better, but alas, they are still alive. Extraordinary crop in secondary actress category - any one of them could have won.
Sean Penn was totally awesome in "Milk", no questions there (haven't seen "The Wrestler" yet, I admit). Between Kate Winslet and Meryl Streep - tough choice, everyone else was a class below at least, although Angelina in Changeling was surprisingly good (Mr. Eastwood has a hand for directing women, he really does).
"The Duchess" winning costume award was more than deserved as was makeup for "Benjamin Button", cinematography and art direction are debatable, as all nominated movies were great.
Editing could have gone to "Milk" or "Dark Knight", but in this case I'm OK with Slumdog winning - they were equals. For best score I was sort of rooting for "Defiance", but Mumbai folclore was the flavour of the day (night).
The "commie homo-loving sons of guns" must think that the right message for the tough times is that the kids in the slums are happy and lovely (unless someone takes their eyes or legs to make them more efficient beggars), when they grow up - despite malnutrition, lack of hygiene and dental/medical care of any sort - they will have lovely faces, clear skin, good hair and teeth, they will also learn good English and manners while stealing from tourists. And of course, life will reward them with the girl of their dreams (second-hand but still) and a significant monetary prize. Let's hold hands and do the happy Bollywood dance. Yay. Meanwhile, Obama will fix the world for us.
PS. Hugh Jackman can sing!
I am disappointed with Bollywood "poor boy meets girl and wins lottery because he's nice" story getting 8 Oscars, I really am. The Academy took the feel good route and seriously overdid it with all the cheerful spirit for the times of crisis.
Best song? WTF?
"Milk" and "The Reader" were much more movie movies, "Benjamin Button" was not bad either, but nooo... the happy beggar wins. Bleh. I'm disappointed "Changeling" and "Revolutionary Road" didn't get the recognition they deserved.
As much as I loved Heath Ledger - enough is enough, Philip Seymour Hoffman and Michael Shannon were as good if not better, but alas, they are still alive. Extraordinary crop in secondary actress category - any one of them could have won.
Sean Penn was totally awesome in "Milk", no questions there (haven't seen "The Wrestler" yet, I admit). Between Kate Winslet and Meryl Streep - tough choice, everyone else was a class below at least, although Angelina in Changeling was surprisingly good (Mr. Eastwood has a hand for directing women, he really does).
"The Duchess" winning costume award was more than deserved as was makeup for "Benjamin Button", cinematography and art direction are debatable, as all nominated movies were great.
Editing could have gone to "Milk" or "Dark Knight", but in this case I'm OK with Slumdog winning - they were equals. For best score I was sort of rooting for "Defiance", but Mumbai folclore was the flavour of the day (night).
The "commie homo-loving sons of guns" must think that the right message for the tough times is that the kids in the slums are happy and lovely (unless someone takes their eyes or legs to make them more efficient beggars), when they grow up - despite malnutrition, lack of hygiene and dental/medical care of any sort - they will have lovely faces, clear skin, good hair and teeth, they will also learn good English and manners while stealing from tourists. And of course, life will reward them with the girl of their dreams (second-hand but still) and a significant monetary prize. Let's hold hands and do the happy Bollywood dance. Yay. Meanwhile, Obama will fix the world for us.
PS. Hugh Jackman can sing!
Labels: Oscars Academy Slumdog Milk reader movie actor award
posted by Karyatis at 12:03 am
0 Comments:
Post a Comment
<< Home